ORPHANS at the Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre

(Seen April 24, 2013)


Lyle Kessler's three-character play explores the relationship of two adult brothers, and a stranger who intrudes in their totally dysfunctional family life.  Treat, the older brother (Ben Foster) keeps his younger sibling, Phillip (Tom Sturridge) in a feral, juvenile state, afraid to leave their run-down Philadelphia house.

One day, Treat, a petty criminal, brings home an inebriated Harold (Alec Baldwin), thinking him to be a rich businessman who he could hold prisoner until a ransom is paid.  The bumbling brothers soon discover that Harold is a gangster, who easily frees himself, but decides to stay on as the boys' surrogate father.

The play's reversal of fortunes add a new dynamic to the relationships.  Director Daniel Sullivan, despite the histrionics of the situation, brings out the many light-hearted moments.  The strong cast, particularly Baldwin, seems to enjoy the proceedings.  Role reversals between the brothers, and a tragic ending, makes for a strong drama.